Pencil or Full? How to Choose an Artificial Christmas Tree in Canada

An artificial tree is a one-time buy that comes out every December, so it is worth choosing by the space it has to fit. Health Canada says to buy holiday lights with a Canadian certification mark (CSA, cUL or cETL), and the Canada Safety Council says to look for a fire resistant label on an artificial tree. Here are four top sellers, and the two questions to answer first: how wide is the spot, and do you want a slim pencil shape or a full one?

Quick answer

Affiliate links (paid links) below. Details

Measure the spot first. A pencil tree lists a width around 26 inches, and a full tree lists a base of 42 to 49 inches. Then check the box for a Canadian certification mark on the lights and a fire resistant label on the tree.

A simple place to start: the SHareconn 6 ft Prelit Pencil Tree. The product page lists 6 ft, a 26 inch diameter, 200 pre-strung warm lights and three sections with no tools. Want a fuller shape? Look at the SHareconn 6 ft Classic Spruce.

Card reading How To Choose An Artificial Christmas Tree, with a lit tree

Four pre-lit trees, by what they suit

ProductBest for
SHareconn 6 ft Prelit Pencil TreeBest for a narrow spot such as a corner or a small room. The product page lists 6 ft, a 26 inch diameter, 637 tips, 200 incandescent warm lights with removable bulbs, UL Listed bulbs, flame-retardant PVC branches, three sections, a steel stand and no tools. 800+ bought in the past month when we checked.See price
SHareconn 6 ft Classic Spruce TreeBest for a fuller look in a bigger room. The product page lists 6 ft including the stand, a 42 inch base, 900 tips, 200 warm white lights, bulbs that meet a UL standard and stay lit if one burns out, three hinged sections and a foldable metal base with one screw. 700+ bought in the past month when we checked.See price
SHareconn 6 ft Hinged Pencil Tree, Multi-ColorBest for a slim tree with a choice of light colours. The product page lists 6 ft, 669 tips, 200 LED lights in warm white and multicolor, a remote with 5 brightness levels, 17 modes, 23 timers and memory (2 AAA batteries not included), PVC with a “fireproof function”, three parts and a folding steel stand. 600+ bought in the past month when we checked.See price
SHareconn 7 ft Prelit Classic Tree with RemoteBest for a high ceiling and a wide spot. The product page lists 7 ft including the stand, a 49 inch base, 280 dual-colour LED lights, 1112 PVC tips, a remote with 23 timers, 5 brightness levels, 5 speeds, 17 modes and memory, flame-retardant PVC and a foldable stand. 300+ bought in the past month when we checked.See price

All four are from one brand because they were the top sellers when we checked, so this is a comparison of shapes and sizes, not of brands. Features come from the product pages and can change, so check the current description before you order.

Pencil or full: which one fits your room?

The two shapes trade width for fullness. The pencil tree on our list lists a 26 inch diameter and 637 tips, while the classic spruce lists a 42 inch base and 900 tips, and the 7 ft classic lists a 49 inch base and 1112 tips. Measure the floor space and the ceiling height at home, then compare them with the height (including the stand) and base diameter on each product page.

What does Health Canada say about holiday lights?

Health Canada says to buy lights with a Canadian certification mark: CSA, cUL or cETL. It also says to check the bulbs and throw out strings with frayed or exposed wires, to avoid plugging too many lights into one outlet because overloaded circuits can overheat, and to turn holiday lights off before bed or before leaving home. The product pages for our four picks say “UL Listed” or “UL standard” bulbs, which is not the same wording, so look at the box or the cord tag for a CSA, cUL or cETL mark before you plug a tree in.

What should the tree itself be labelled?

The Canada Safety Council says an artificial tree should carry a fire resistant label and a CSA label. It adds that “fire resistant” does not mean a tree cannot burn, only that it should resist catching fire and go out quickly. Our four picks list flame-retardant PVC, or PVC with a “fireproof function”, but that is the seller’s wording, so look for the label itself on the box.

How do you set up a pre-lit tree safely?

  • Keep it away from heat. The Canada Safety Council says to keep an artificial tree away from fireplaces and heaters.
  • Don’t overload the outlet. Health Canada says too many lights in one outlet can overheat the circuit, and the Canada Safety Council says not to connect more than three light sets to one extension cord.
  • Check the cords every year. Health Canada says to check the bulbs and discard strings with frayed or exposed wires.
  • Turn the lights off. Health Canada says to switch holiday lights off before bed or before you leave the house. A tree with a remote that lists a timer can help with this.
  • No extra light strings on a metal tree. The Canada Safety Council says not to use electric light strings on a metallic tree.

What should you look for in a tree?

  • Height and width. Our picks list 6 ft or 7 ft including the stand, with a base from 26 inches (pencil) to 49 inches. Match both to your space.
  • Lights. The pencil tree lists 200 incandescent warm lights with removable bulbs, the classic spruce lists 200 warm white lights that stay lit if one burns out, and the other two list LED lights with a remote.
  • Tips. The product pages list 637 to 1112 tips. More tips mean a fuller look, but a bigger tree.
  • Setup and storage. The product pages list three sections and a folding stand, and the pencil tree lists no tools needed.
  • Labels. A CSA, cUL or cETL mark on the lights and a fire resistant label on the tree.

Common questions

Is a pencil tree better for a small room? It lists a narrower base, 26 inches on the SHareconn pencil model against 42 to 49 inches for the full ones, so it takes less floor space. Measure first.

Can I add more lights to a pre-lit tree? Health Canada warns against plugging too many lights into one outlet, and the Canada Safety Council says no more than three light sets on one extension cord. Check the maker’s instructions for how many sets can connect.

Do I need a certification mark on the tree or the lights? Health Canada names CSA, cUL and cETL for lights. The Canada Safety Council names a fire resistant label and a CSA label for the tree.

Before you buy

  • Measure the floor space and the ceiling height.
  • Compare them with the height and base diameter on each product page.
  • Look for a CSA, cUL or cETL mark on the lights and a fire resistant label on the tree.
  • Decide between warm lights only and a remote with colours and timers.
  • Plan where it goes: away from fireplaces and heaters, with one outlet that is not overloaded.

Sources: Health Canada, Holiday decoration, apparel and gift safety; Canada Safety Council, Have a safe, fire-free holiday season. Product details come from the product pages of the four trees, so check the current description before you order.

Our top pick: SHareconn 6 ft Prelit Pencil Tree

Lists a 26 inch width and 200 pre-strung lights.

Card reading Our Top Pick SHareconn 6 ft Prelit Pencil Tree, lists a 26 inch width and 200 pre-strung lights

Get new buying guides by email.

We send new guides only, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Free: your home, season by season

A printable four-season checklist with the jobs that keep a home safe, dry and warm.